20 min read
Unrepeatered Submarine Transmission Systems: Technologies and Deployment
Introduction
Unrepeatered submarine transmission systems represent a specialized category of optical communication infrastructure designed to bridge distances up to 600+ kilometers without the need for active repeaters on the seafloor. Unlike long-haul repeatered systems that employ optical amplifiers every 60-100 km along the route, unrepeatered systems achieve their extended reach through advanced optical amplification techniques deployed entirely from the terminal stations.
The fundamental distinction lies in the system architecture. Unrepeatered links contain no active electronics requiring electrical power on the submarine cable itself. This eliminates the need for copper power conductors within the cable structure, significantly reducing complexity, cost, and potential failure points. Instead, these systems rely on distributed Raman amplification and remote optically pumped amplifiers (ROPAs) that derive their energy from optical pump lasers located in the cable landing stations.
The value proposition of unrepeatered systems becomes particularly compelling for short-to-medium submarine routes where the total system cost, installation complexity, and operational reliability must be optimized. Applications include island connectivity, cross-border links, festoon networks, and data center interconnections where distances range from 100 to 600 kilometers.
Modern unrepeatered systems leverage coherent optical transmission at 100 Gbps and beyond, combined with advanced forward error correction, to achieve spectral efficiencies and reach performance that were unattainable just a decade ago. The continuous evolution of ultra-low-loss fibers, high-power pump lasers, and digital signal processing has progressively extended the maximum achievable distance from around 250 km in the early 2000s to over 600 km today.
Key Concepts and Technologies
Distributed Raman Amplification
Distributed Raman amplification forms the cornerstone technology enabling unrepeatered transmission. Unlike discrete optical amplifiers that provide gain at specific locations, Raman amplification occurs continuously throughout the transmission fiber itself. When high-power pump lasers (typically operating at wavelengths 100 nm shorter than the signal wavelengths) are launched into the fiber, they transfer energy to the signal channels through stimulated Raman scattering.
The key advantage of distributed amplification lies in maintaining a more uniform signal power profile along the fiber span. Instead of the signal experiencing dramatic attenuation followed by discrete amplification, the power varies more gradually. This reduces the peak power requirements and consequently minimizes fiber nonlinearities such as self-phase modulation, cross-phase modulation, and four-wave mixing.
Raman pump configurations can be implemented in three modes: backward pumping (pump propagates opposite to signal direction), forward pumping (pump co-propagates with signal), or bidirectional pumping (combination of both). Backward pumping is most common as it provides superior noise figure performance, though forward pumping can extend reach further by supporting the signal earlier in its propagation path.
Technical Insight: Raman Gain Spectrum
The Raman gain spectrum in silica fiber exhibits a broad peak approximately 13 THz (100 nm) below the pump wavelength. For C-band DWDM systems operating around 1550 nm, typical pump wavelengths range from 1420 to 1480 nm. Multiple pump wavelengths are often deployed to flatten the gain spectrum across the entire signal band, ensuring uniform amplification for all channels.
Remote Optically Pumped Amplifiers (ROPA)
A ROPA is a passive optical device deployed on the submarine cable at distances typically ranging from 80 to 140 km from the shore terminals. The device consists of erbium-doped fiber (EDF) spliced into the transmission path, surrounded by optical isolators and wavelength-selective couplers, all housed within a pressure-resistant enclosure.
The critical distinction from conventional EDFAs is that the ROPA contains no active electronics and requires no electrical power. Instead, optical pump energy is delivered remotely through the transmission fiber itself. Backward ROPAs receive residual Raman pump power (typically at 1480 nm) that was not consumed during distributed amplification. This residual power, often just 5-10 mW, is sufficient to excite the erbium ions and provide 20-25 dB of optical gain.
ROPA placement optimization involves balancing multiple factors: maximizing overall link gain while minimizing noise accumulation, ensuring adequate pump power reaches the ROPA location, and maintaining sufficient margin for cable repairs. Advanced designs may incorporate dual ROPAs (one near each terminal) for spans exceeding 500 km, or employ separate pump delivery fibers for extended reach applications.
Ultra-Low-Loss Optical Fiber
The transmission fiber itself represents a critical enabling technology for unrepeatered systems. Modern ultra-low-loss fibers achieve attenuation coefficients as low as 0.146 dB/km at 1550 nm, compared to standard single-mode fiber at approximately 0.20 dB/km. While this difference appears modest, across a 300 km span it translates to a 16 dB improvement in link budget.
These specialized fibers combine several design innovations. Pure silica core designs minimize Rayleigh scattering losses. Large effective area (typically 110-150 μm²) reduces nonlinear effects by lowering optical intensity. Careful control of dopant concentrations and manufacturing processes ensures minimal absorption peaks and scattering centers.
The trade-off involves increased fiber cost and handling sensitivity. Large effective area fibers exhibit reduced bending tolerance and require careful installation procedures. Splice losses must be minimized through precision alignment, as each connector or splice introduces additional loss that directly impacts the overall link budget.
Coherent Detection and Digital Signal Processing
Coherent optical receivers have revolutionized unrepeatered transmission performance. Unlike direct detection systems that discard phase information, coherent receivers utilize a local oscillator laser to extract both amplitude and phase of the received optical field. This enables reception at lower optical signal-to-noise ratios (OSNR), typically providing 6-10 dB improvement in receiver sensitivity compared to intensity modulation with direct detection.
The digital signal processing (DSP) subsystem performs critical equalization functions. Chromatic dispersion compensation, previously requiring bulky dispersion-compensating modules, occurs entirely in the digital domain. Polarization mode dispersion tracking adapts dynamically to varying fiber conditions. Advanced algorithms can partially compensate for fiber nonlinearities, though this remains an active research area.
Modern coherent transceivers support polarization-division multiplexed quadrature amplitude modulation formats (PDM-QPSK, PDM-16QAM, PDM-64QAM), allowing flexible trade-offs between reach and spectral efficiency. For unrepeatered applications, PM-QPSK at 100G or 200G provides the optimal balance, offering robust performance at reduced OSNR requirements.
Practical Applications and Use Cases
Island Connectivity
Island nations and archipelagos represent prime applications for unrepeatered systems. Routes connecting mainland facilities to islands typically span 150-400 km, falling squarely within unrepeatered capabilities. The elimination of active subsea equipment dramatically reduces installation costs and simplifies maintenance, as cable repairs require no specialized handling of powered repeaters.
Examples include connections between Taiwan and offshore islands, Mediterranean island links, and Caribbean inter-island systems. These deployments often feature higher fiber counts (24-48 fibers) within the cable to support future capacity expansion, a configuration difficult to achieve with repeatered systems due to repeater size constraints.
Cross-Border Links
International borders separated by bodies of water benefit significantly from unrepeatered technology. Routes across the English Channel, Baltic Sea crossings, Southeast Asian straits, and Gulf of Mexico spans typically measure 50-300 km. The ability to deploy systems rapidly without complex repeater logistics reduces time-to-market for new capacity.
Regulatory advantages emerge as well. Unrepeatered cables avoid the complications of maintaining powered equipment in international waters, simplifying permitting and ongoing operational compliance. Cable repair procedures become more straightforward, as any marine vessel with standard splicing capability can perform restorations.
Festoon Networks and Metro Extensions
Coastal festoon networks connecting multiple landing points often deploy unrepeatered segments. These configurations provide diverse routing paths and enable reconfigurable network topologies using ROADM technology. Metro network operators extend their terrestrial infrastructure into the submarine domain, creating seamless optical layers that traverse land and sea without protocol conversion.
The integration with terrestrial DWDM systems allows end-to-end wavelength services. A lambda originating in a data center can traverse terrestrial fiber, submarine unrepeatered spans, and additional terrestrial segments without regeneration, significantly reducing operational complexity and latency.
Data Center Interconnection
Cloud service providers and content delivery networks increasingly deploy dedicated submarine cables for data center interconnection. Unrepeatered systems provide high-capacity, low-latency links between coastal data center facilities. The simplified architecture aligns well with rapid deployment cycles and automation-driven operations typical of hyperscale environments.
Recent trends toward shorter submarine routes (100-250 km) connecting major urban centers favor unrepeatered solutions. The elimination of active subsea components reduces power consumption and aligns with sustainability objectives. Multiple fiber pairs support diverse traffic demands while maintaining cost-effectiveness.
| Application Type | Typical Distance | Primary Benefits | Common Configurations |
|---|---|---|---|
| Island Connectivity | 150-400 km | Simplified maintenance, high fiber count | Single ROPA, 24-48 fibers |
| Cross-Border Links | 50-300 km | Fast deployment, regulatory simplicity | Distributed Raman only or single ROPA |
| Festoon Networks | 100-350 km | Network flexibility, diverse routing | ROADM integration, multiple fiber pairs |
| Data Center Interconnect | 100-250 km | Low latency, rapid provisioning | High fiber count, automation-ready |
| Utility/Pipeline Routes | 200-450 km | Leverages existing infrastructure | Dual ROPA for extended reach |
Design Considerations and Limitations
Optical Power Budget and Link Design
Unrepeatered system design centers on careful power budget management. The fundamental equation balances transmitter output power, fiber attenuation, amplifier gains, and receiver sensitivity. Unlike repeatered systems where EDFA stages provide fixed gain-loss compensation, unrepeatered links must account for distributed gain profiles that vary with fiber characteristics and pump power.
Typical link budgets for modern systems achieve 95-100 dB total loss compensation. This comprises transmitter output power (15-20 dBm aggregate for DWDM), distributed Raman gain (10-15 dB), ROPA gains (20-25 dB each if dual-ROPA), and coherent receiver sensitivity (-40 to -45 dBm). Margins of 3-6 dB accommodate aging, repair cable, and component degradation over the system lifetime.
The signal power evolution along the fiber span requires careful optimization. Excessive power causes nonlinear impairments, while insufficient power degrades OSNR. Computer simulations incorporating full propagation equations help designers identify optimal launch powers, pump powers, and ROPA placement locations.
Critical Design Constraint: Fiber Nonlinearities
Self-phase modulation, cross-phase modulation, and four-wave mixing increase dramatically with optical power and transmission distance. Unrepeatered systems operate at higher per-channel powers than repeatered links, making nonlinearity management essential. Large effective area fiber, optimized dispersion maps, and careful channel power allocation help mitigate these effects, but ultimately limit the achievable spectral efficiency over very long spans.
Noise Accumulation and OSNR Degradation
Optical amplifiers introduce amplified spontaneous emission (ASE) noise that accumulates along the transmission path. Distributed Raman amplification exhibits better noise performance than discrete EDFAs because it provides gain where the signal is weakest, improving the instantaneous signal-to-noise ratio throughout the span.
ROPA noise figure typically measures 4-5 dB, comparable to or better than conventional EDFAs. However, the cumulative OSNR at the receiver depends on the interplay between signal attenuation, distributed gain, and discrete amplification. Advanced designs employ multiple pump wavelengths and optimized pump power allocation to minimize noise figure while maximizing gain.
For systems approaching 600 km reach, achieving adequate OSNR (typically 15-18 dB for PM-QPSK) requires advanced forward error correction codes with 20-25% overhead. Soft-decision FEC algorithms can recover signals at lower OSNR values but introduce additional latency and power consumption in the terminal equipment.
Stimulated Brillouin Scattering Threshold
Stimulated Brillouin scattering (SBS) imposes a fundamental limit on the maximum optical power that can be launched into the fiber. In standard single-mode fiber, the SBS threshold sits around 6-8 dBm per channel. Above this level, backward-scattered light extracts energy from the forward-propagating signal, degrading transmission performance.
Mitigation strategies include fiber design modifications (varying the core dopant profile to broaden the Brillouin gain spectrum), phase modulation of the carrier to spread the optical linewidth, and optimizing the transmitter spectral characteristics. Large effective area fibers inherently exhibit higher SBS thresholds due to reduced optical intensity.
System Capacity Limitations
While modern repeatered systems can transport 20+ Tbps per fiber pair across transoceanic distances, unrepeatered systems typically deliver 1-5 Tbps over their maximum reach spans. The capacity limitation arises from the trade-off between reach and spectral efficiency. Higher-order modulation formats (16QAM, 64QAM) require better OSNR, forcing reductions in distance or channel count.
For spans below 400 km, unrepeatered systems can achieve competitive capacity densities using PM-16QAM at 200G per wavelength. However, as distance extends toward 500-600 km, reverting to PM-QPSK becomes necessary, effectively halving the bits-per-symbol and total system capacity.
The higher fiber count available in unrepeatered cables partially compensates for per-fiber capacity constraints. A 48-fiber cable with 2 Tbps per fiber pair delivers competitive aggregate capacity while maintaining the architectural simplicity and reliability advantages of the unrepeatered approach.
Implementation Best Practices
System Planning and Design Optimization
Successful unrepeatered system deployment begins with comprehensive route planning. Accurate bathymetric surveys identify potential obstacles, cable landing sites, and ROPA placement locations. The fiber route should minimize sharp bends, avoid areas with significant marine activity, and account for future repair scenarios.
Link budget calculations must incorporate worst-case conditions: maximum fiber loss due to temperature variations, component aging degradation typically 1-2 dB over 25-year lifetime, and repair cable margins allowing for at least one cable restoration. Conservative design margins (3-6 dB) ensure long-term reliability despite environmental uncertainties.
Simulation tools modeling the complete transmission path help optimize pump wavelength selection, power allocation between forward and backward pumping, and ROPA gain requirements. These simulations account for Raman gain spectrum shaping, nonlinear effects at various power levels, and ASE noise accumulation throughout the amplification chain.
Installation and Commissioning
Cable installation follows marine practices established for repeatered systems but with simplified procedures due to absence of active equipment. The ROPA enclosure, being passive and smaller than powered repeaters, allows for more flexible handling and reduced installation risk. Post-installation OTDR measurements verify splice quality, fiber continuity, and overall loss characteristics.
Commissioning procedures establish baseline performance metrics for all optical channels. Measurements include per-channel OSNR, chromatic dispersion characterization, and bit error rate testing across the full environmental operating range. These baseline values guide future maintenance and troubleshooting efforts.
Raman pump laser alignment requires careful optimization to balance gain flatness across the DWDM spectrum while avoiding excessive nonlinearity. Pump power is typically ramped gradually while monitoring channel performance to identify optimal operating points. Automatic gain control circuits adjust pump power dynamically to compensate for component aging and temperature variations.
Monitoring and Maintenance
Continuous performance monitoring tracks critical parameters including channel power levels, OSNR values, bit error rates, and pump laser operating conditions. Modern systems employ embedded telemetry channels or optical supervisory channels (OSC) for bidirectional communication between terminals, enabling real-time status reporting.
Coherent receivers provide detailed diagnostic capabilities through DSP telemetry. Parameters such as chromatic dispersion, polarization mode dispersion, and instantaneous SNR offer insights into fiber conditions and help predict potential issues before service impact occurs.
Cable repair procedures for unrepeatered systems follow standard submarine practices but benefit from the absence of powered components. Any repair vessel with fiber splicing capability can perform restorations, eliminating the specialized equipment and procedures required for repeater handling. The system automatically resumes operation once fiber continuity is restored and pump power reaches the appropriate levels.
Operational Best Practice: Preventive Pump Management
Raman pump lasers represent the most critical active components in unrepeatered systems. Implementing redundant pump configurations with automatic failover capability ensures continued operation despite individual laser failures. Regular pump power margin testing verifies adequate headroom for end-of-life conditions. Proactive pump replacement based on operating hours rather than failure occurrence maximizes system availability.
Upgrade and Expansion Strategies
The modular nature of unrepeatered systems facilitates capacity upgrades. Terminal equipment can be replaced with higher-performance transponders supporting advanced modulation formats or increased channel counts without modifying the submarine plant. This dark fiber upgrade capability represents a significant economic advantage compared to repeatered systems requiring amplifier bandwidth considerations.
Multi-fiber cables enable phased deployment strategies. Initial system activation may utilize a subset of fiber pairs, with additional pairs lit as demand grows. This approach spreads capital expenditure over time while maintaining physical infrastructure capable of supporting ultimate capacity requirements.
Technology evolution paths include migration to space-division multiplexing using multi-core or few-mode fibers, though these remain research topics for submarine applications. More immediately, improvements in DSP algorithms and error correction coding can extract additional performance from existing fiber infrastructure through software upgrades.
Conclusion
Unrepeatered submarine transmission systems occupy a critical niche in global optical communications infrastructure. By eliminating active subsea electronics through innovative application of distributed Raman amplification, remote optical pumping, and advanced coherent detection, these systems deliver reliable, cost-effective connectivity across distances approaching 600 kilometers.
The technology synthesis enabling modern unrepeatered systems demonstrates the power of integrated optical engineering. Ultra-low-loss fibers provide the fundamental transmission medium. High-power pump lasers and carefully designed ROPAs extend reach beyond what simple fiber would allow. Coherent receivers with sophisticated DSP extract maximum performance from challenging signal conditions. Each element contributes essential capabilities that collectively enable the complete solution.
Looking forward, continued improvements in fiber loss characteristics, pump laser efficiency, and DSP algorithms will incrementally extend achievable distances and capacities. The growing demand for data center interconnection and regional connectivity ensures unrepeatered systems remain relevant despite the impressive capabilities of modern repeatered networks. Their architectural simplicity, operational reliability, and economic advantages make them the preferred solution for medium-distance submarine routes.
For network planners and system designers, unrepeatered technology offers a proven, mature solution backed by extensive deployment experience and ongoing vendor innovation. Understanding the underlying physics, design trade-offs, and operational considerations enables optimal system specification and deployment strategies. As optical communications continue evolving toward higher capacities and greater reach, unrepeatered systems will maintain their important role in the global communications ecosystem.
References
- ITU-T Recommendation G.973, "Characteristics of optical systems for unrepeatered submarine cable systems," International Telecommunication Union, 2016. Available: https://www.itu.int/rec/T-REC-G.973
- Bromage, J., "Raman amplification for fiber communications systems," IEEE Journal of Lightwave Technology, vol. 22, no. 1, pp. 79-93, 2004.
- Pelouch, W.S., "Raman Amplification: An Enabling Technology for Long-Haul Coherent Transmission Systems," Journal of Lightwave Technology, vol. 34, no. 1, pp. 6-19, Jan. 2016.
- Chang, D., et al., "150 x 120 Gb/s unrepeatered transmission over 409.6 km using commercial Raman DWDM system," Optical Fiber Communications Conference (OFC), 2014.
- Gainov, V., et al., "Record 500 km unrepeatered 1 Tbit/s (10 x 100G) transmission over an ultra-low loss fiber," Optics Express, vol. 22, no. 19, pp. 22308-13, 2014.
- Makovejs, S., et al., "Record-Low (0.1460 dB/km) Attenuation Ultra-Large Aeff Optical Fiber for Submarine Applications," Optical Fiber Communications Conference (OFC), 2015.
- IEEE Standard 802.3ba-2010, "IEEE Standard for Ethernet – Amendment 4: Media Access Control Parameters, Physical Layers and Management Parameters for 40 Gb/s and 100 Gb/s Operation," 2010.
- Submarine Telecoms Forum, "Submarine Cable Almanac," Available: http://subtelforum.com
For educational purposes in optical networking and DWDM systems
Note: This guide is based on industry standards, best practices, and real-world implementation experiences. Specific implementations may vary based on equipment vendors, network topology, and regulatory requirements. Always consult with qualified network engineers and follow vendor documentation for actual deployments.
Unlock Premium Content
Join over 400K+ optical network professionals worldwide. Access premium courses, advanced engineering tools, and exclusive industry insights.
Already have an account? Log in here